Ukraine Peace Talks: 5 Signs a Deal Remains Elusive
Ukraine peace talks have continued through diplomatic meetings in Norway and Russia, but the prospect of ending the war remains uncertain despite renewed discussions involving the United States, Ukraine and European representatives.
Meetings in Oslo and St Petersburg brought together officials seeking a way forward, with Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre describing Tuesday’s discussions as “good and constructive”. The talks involved Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, US President Donald Trump’s special envoy Steve Witkoff and European representatives.
The discussions raised the possibility of a trilateral summit involving Zelensky, Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin. However, no such meeting appears imminent, while Moscow’s response to the latest diplomatic efforts has cast doubt on how much progress has been made.
Witkoff acknowledged that significant work remained, writing on X that “there is still important work to do”. He added that “President Trump remains committed to seeing this war end”.
1. Ukraine Peace Talks Face Uncertainty Over a Leaders’ Summit
The prospect of a meeting between Trump, Zelensky and Putin had emerged as a potential outcome of the latest diplomatic activity.
The hope was that Witkoff’s visit to Russia would build on discussions in Oslo and help pave the way for a leaders’ summit aimed at reaching an agreement to end the fighting.
However, Putin has shown little willingness to meet Zelensky outside Moscow, according to the account of the diplomatic discussions.
The Kremlin has indicated that it may be prepared to resume trilateral talks involving Russia, Ukraine and the United States next month in Abu Dhabi. Those discussions, however, would take place at the technical level rather than between national leaders.
The distinction matters because technical negotiations and a summit between presidents serve different purposes. While officials can explore possible arrangements, a leaders’ meeting would provide an opportunity for the parties to address major political questions directly.
For now, the proposed summit remains uncertain, with no confirmed agreement emerging from the meetings in Norway and Russia.
2. Kremlin Adviser Questions Value of Oslo Discussions
One of the clearest indications of Moscow’s position came from Yuri Ushakov, a foreign policy adviser to Putin who participated in the St Petersburg talks.
Ushakov said Witkoff had briefed the Russian president on the Oslo discussions and what the US envoy described as “new approaches from the Europeans and Kyiv”.
However, the Kremlin adviser expressed reservations about the proposals.
“In terms of resolving the Ukraine crisis, there wasn’t much there that was useful,” Ushakov said.
His assessment suggested that the discussions had not produced proposals Moscow considered sufficiently useful to advance a settlement.
When Russian state television later asked about the prospects for peace, Ushakov offered a more ambiguous response.
“I don’t know how close we are getting,” he said, “but things are moving in that direction.”
The comments offered little clarity about the pace of negotiations or the conditions under which Russia might agree to end the war.
Although Ushakov suggested that discussions were moving forward, his criticism of the Oslo proposals highlighted the differences that continue to complicate diplomatic efforts.
3. Putin Faces Questions Over Pressure to End the War
The latest diplomatic exchanges have raised questions about whether Putin feels sufficient pressure to make concessions.
The assessment presented in the account of the talks is that the Russian president may see little immediate reason to change course.
Ukraine’s air defences are under severe strain, while the approaching winter could create additional challenges for the country. The assessment also suggests that Moscow may view the colder months as an opportunity to intensify pressure on Ukraine.
Relations between Washington and Moscow are another important factor.
Trump has expressed interest in developing a stronger relationship with Russia. Recent moves described in the account include pausing some sanctions on Moscow, agreeing to buy Russian diesel and criticising Zelensky.
These developments have fuelled debate over whether US policy is increasing Moscow’s incentive to negotiate or reducing the pressure on the Kremlin.
The latest talks have not resolved that question, and the different positions of the parties remain a significant obstacle to a settlement.
4. Russian Support for Trump’s Peace Efforts
Some Russian officials have portrayed Trump’s approach as a positive development for peace.
Russian MP and television presenter Evgeny Popov said: “Right now Trump is the only leader in the Western world who is doing something for peace.”
When asked whether he meant peace on Russia’s terms, Popov responded: “Of course!”
The exchange illustrates the disagreement over what a potential peace agreement would involve.
Diplomatic efforts may bring the parties closer to negotiations, but agreement on the terms of a settlement remains a separate challenge. The latest discussions have not established that Russia, Ukraine and the United States share the same vision for ending the conflict.
The prospect of a deal therefore depends not only on whether leaders are willing to meet, but also on whether they can find common ground on the conditions for peace.
5. Putin, Trump and Xi Could Meet at China’s APEC Summit Ukraine peace talks
Although a trilateral meeting focused on Ukraine may not happen soon, another potential diplomatic gathering could give Putin an opportunity to engage with major global powers.
A meeting involving Putin, Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping may take place in China next month on the sidelines of the APEC summit.
Some commentators have already described the possibility as “The New Yalta”, referring to the 1945 conference where Soviet leader Joseph Stalin, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill and US President Franklin D. Roosevelt discussed the political and territorial reorganisation of post-war Europe.
Popov argued that Russia, China and the United States were the world’s only superpowers and said a meeting between their leaders would benefit the international community.
Whether such a meeting takes place remains uncertain, and it would not necessarily produce an agreement on Ukraine.
Nevertheless, the possibility highlights how the war has become intertwined with broader questions about relations among the world’s major powers.
Ukraine War Peace Prospects Remain Unclear Ukraine peace talks
The latest diplomatic activity has kept negotiations alive, but there is little evidence yet of a breakthrough.
Norway’s description of the Oslo talks as constructive contrasts with Ushakov’s criticism of the proposals discussed. Meanwhile, the Kremlin’s willingness to consider technical-level negotiations does not guarantee that a meeting between Putin, Zelensky and Trump will follow.
The wider political context also remains important, particularly the relationship between Washington and Moscow and the military pressures facing Ukraine.
After nearly five years of war, the prospect of a settlement continues to depend on whether diplomatic engagement can overcome differences over the terms of peace.
For now, the meetings in Oslo and St Petersburg represent continued efforts to find a way forward, rather than clear evidence that the conflict is close to ending.
